The social media graveyard on your homepage

At the bottom of your website, there they are: the familiar icons. Facebook. Instagram. LinkedIn. X. Maybe even Pinterest or TikTok. They’re there “because it’s expected.” Because every template includes them by default. Because your competitor has them too.

But have you ever thought about what happens when someone clicks on them?

What the visitor sees

The visitor clicks your Instagram icon. They land on a profile with 47 followers and a last post from early 2024. Or a Facebook page where the latest update is a Christmas greeting from two years ago. Or a LinkedIn profile without a photo and with three connections.

The signal is devastating: this company has stopped investing. Or worse: this company might not exist anymore.

It’s like having a beautiful shop, but in the window there’s a yellowed sign reading “Follow us on Twitter!” pointing to an account that’s been silent for years. The customer doubts — not your product, but your reliability.

The threefold problem

Dead social media links aren’t just a signal of neglect. They’re a massive conversion leak:

Problem 1: You’re sending warm traffic away. Every click on a social media icon is a visitor leaving your website. They go from your controlled environment (where the call-to-action is, where the contact form is, where your story is told) to a platform that invests billions in never letting the user’s attention go. The chance they’ll return to your site is minimal.

Problem 2: You lose control. On your website, you decide what the visitor sees. On Facebook or Instagram, the algorithm decides. There you compete directly with cat videos, holiday photos, and your competitor’s ads. You’ve literally sent the visitor from your own calm shop into an overstimulating shopping centre.

Problem 3: It communicates uncertainty. A website packed with social media buttons unconsciously says: “I don’t trust my own content to keep you here.” A website without those buttons radiates authority: “Everything you need is right here.”

When social media links are appropriate

There’s exactly one situation where social media links belong on your site: when you actively and professionally maintain those channels, and when they serve a clear function in your customer journey.

A restaurant with an active Instagram full of beautiful dishes? Makes sense. A photographer with a portfolio on Instagram that’s updated weekly? Fine. A coach with an active LinkedIn where she shares weekly insights? Can work.

But a plumber with an empty Facebook page? A painter with an Instagram without photos? An accountant with an X account that’s never been used? Get rid of them.

The rule of thumb

Ask yourself this question about each icon: “If a potential customer clicks this, will they become more or less convinced to contact me?”

If the answer is “less” — or even “I don’t know” — then that icon doesn’t belong on your site.

The radical solution

Remove them. All of them. Unless you can prove they actively contribute to your conversion.

A website that trusts its own content doesn’t need digital mannequins. No empty profiles as decoration. No buttons that lead your visitor away from where they should be: on your site, with your story, at your contact form.

It’s the difference between a shopkeeper who sends you out the front door to “have a look at the neighbours too,” and a shopkeeper who says: “Everything you’re looking for is right here. Welcome.”

The 3-second check: Open your own website now. Click your social media icons. Is the last post older than 30 days? Then you’re currently driving customers away.

Curious how your website performs? Try the free website check.